Getting Your Style Right: A Language, Not a Costume
Clayton Vance · April 19, 2025 · 5 min read

We've all seen it. The modern farmhouse with a Roman arch. The faux French chateau with a Craftsman porch. The "traditional" home with windows too wide, trim too skinny, and shutters that couldn't possibly close. Somewhere in the frenzy of Pinterest boards, product catalogs, and builder-driven design, we've lost track of what style really is. We treat it like clothing — something we can swap, mix, or accessorize on a whim. But style isn't a costume. Style is a language. And it has to be spoken fluently to make sense.
Style Isn't the Starting Point — It's the Expression
Most people approach style as a starting point: "I want my house to be Colonial Revival" or "We're going modern." But in truth, style is what emerges when deeper decisions are made correctly. It grows from proper massing, clear hierarchy, thoughtful proportion, and contextual material choices. You can't just slap some exposed beams and dark siding on a house and call it mountain modern. That's vocabulary without grammar. Style only works when it's the visible outgrowth of structural and spatial decisions made with intention.
Mixing Styles Isn't Creative — It's Confusing
There's a trend, especially in American residential design, to blend styles. A little Mediterranean. A little Prairie. Maybe a modern farmhouse twist. The result is usually confusion — not richness, not creativity, just noise. Each style has its own rules, its own internal logic that makes it coherent. When you blend two styles without understanding either, you break both. You can't mix languages unless you're fluent in both.
Style Should Come From Context, Not Convenience
Style doesn't just come from taste. It comes from context — climate, region, material availability, historical precedent. There's a reason adobe homes work in the Southwest but not in Vermont, and a reason Georgian symmetry feels grounded in the American South while asymmetrical stone cottages feel right in the English countryside. That doesn't mean we're stuck copying the past. It means we're called to build with memory, not in denial of it.
So How Do You Choose the Right Style?
You don't start by asking what you like. You start by asking: Where is this home — its climate, culture, landscape, and building tradition? What's the massing — what form feels appropriate to the site and program? What's the client's true need — not just aesthetic preferences, but how they want the home to live? What traditions already exist here? Once those questions are answered, style becomes clear. It's not chosen. It's revealed.
Final Thoughts: Clarity Over Cleverness
There's no prize for cleverness in architecture. Only clarity, coherence, care. The homes we remember — photograph, study, love — are rarely the most complex. They are the most consistent. If you're designing a home, don't ask, "Does it look good?" Ask: "Does it make sense? Does it belong? Does it speak one language — or several all at once?" If the answers are yes, you're not just on trend. You're on solid ground.
Further Reading
Form Follows Function... Or Not...
Why purpose — not just function — should shape our buildings. On Sullivan, Le Corbusier, Vitruvius, and why a church door and an outhouse door should never look the same.
Why I Still Believe in Beauty
An introduction to what this space is about — and what's at stake. The kind of beauty that transcends time, and why we need to say out loud that it matters.
